Vitamin A in Pregnancy: Carrots Are Normal, Liver Is Off the List
The NHS says to avoid liver and vitamin pills that contain retinol in pregnancy, and its advice does not name carrots or other orange vegetables. The difference is the form of vitamin A, and the ingredients or nutrition panel is where to check which form a product contains.
At a glance
- Everyday food: orange and yellow fruits and vegetables such as carrots, sweet potatoes, mangos and cantaloupe
- Skip: liver, liver products including fish liver oil, and vitamin pills that list retinol
- Ask first: any pregnancy multivitamin or other vitamin pill, before you buy it or start it
- Why it matters: large amounts of vitamin A in pregnancy can cause birth defects
- Rule to repeat: orange vegetables are the everyday route, and liver is the one to leave out
Prefer to listen? This post as a 4 min video · Watch the video
Why does the NHS say to avoid liver in pregnancy?
Liver and liver products are high in vitamin A, and the NHS says to avoid them in pregnancy for that reason. The same advice covers fish liver oil, which is also high in vitamin A. The NHS also says too much vitamin A can harm the baby’s development. MedlinePlus, the health encyclopedia run by the US National Library of Medicine, is direct about the risk: large amounts of vitamin A in pregnant women can cause birth defects.
Liver is the headline item, but it is not the only food on the list of things folk advice flags. For that wider picture, the foods to avoid list covers the wider list of traditional warnings.
What is the difference between retinol and beta carotene?
Vitamin A reaches the body in two ways. Preformed vitamin A comes from animal foods such as meat, fish, poultry and dairy, and retinol is the name of that form. Provitamin A comes from plants, and the most common type is beta carotene, which the body can turn into vitamin A. The NHS names liver and retinol in its advice and does not mention beta carotene, so the word on the label matters more than the colour of the food.
Which orange foods can you eat as normal food in pregnancy?
Carrots, sweet potatoes, mangos and cantaloupe are the everyday examples MedlinePlus gives for orange and yellow fruits and vegetables. They are food, eaten as part of a normal meal. The NHS warnings name liver, liver products and retinol, and do not name these foods. A katori of carrot cooked into a sabzi, a katori of mashed sweet potato with dinner, a slice of mango after lunch or a bowl of cantaloupe in the evening are ordinary plates. For the iron, folate and calcium side of the plate, the pregnancy diet chart covers those nutrients by katori.
How do you read the vitamin A line on a label?
The vitamin A line is in the nutrition panel, and the form may also be named in the ingredients list. Work through it in this order before you buy or start anything.
- Find the vitamin A line in the nutrition panel, next to the other vitamins.
- If it says retinol, the NHS advice is to avoid that product in pregnancy, so put it back and ask your midwife about another option.
- If it lists beta carotene instead, still bring the pack to your midwife, because the rest of the label and your diet matter too.
- Read the % daily value for vitamin A to see the share it gives, then ask your midwife what amount suits you.
- Write the product name and the vitamin A line in your notes before the antenatal visit, so the midwife can check the same pack.
What about iodine and the other nutrients in pregnancy?
Vitamin A is only one of several nutrients people ask about in pregnancy. Whether you need a multivitamin at all is a separate question, covered in the multivitamins verdict. Iodine has its own answer in the iodised salt guide. This article only covers vitamin A, so the advice here stays narrow on purpose.
Try this before the antenatal visit
Photograph the nutrition panel of every vitamin product in the cupboard, then highlight the vitamin A line on each photo. Bring the pictures or the packs. Two minutes at home means the midwife can answer about the exact product in front of you, not a guess from memory.
Anyone who is pregnant or planning pregnancy should check with a midwife, GP or pharmacist before eating liver or liver products, and before taking any vitamin pill. If you have already eaten liver regularly, or taken a product that lists retinol, and you are worried, speak to your GP, midwife or pharmacist, as the NHS advises. Too much vitamin A can harm the baby’s development, so ask early rather than waiting to see how you feel.
Bottom line: Eat the orange vegetables and fruits as food, leave liver and liver products alone, and avoid vitamin pills that list retinol. Ask your midwife about any other vitamin product before you start it.
Browse more in Vitamins and Minerals.
Vitamin A in pregnancy: the questions people ask
Can I eat carrots during pregnancy?
Yes, carrots are ordinary food. The NHS warnings name liver, liver products and vitamin pills that contain retinol, and the NHS page does not mention carrots. MedlinePlus lists carrots as a food source of provitamin A. Keep them on the plate with the rest of the vegetables, and read the label of any vitamin product you add.
Is liver safe in pregnancy?
No. The NHS advises avoiding liver and liver products in pregnancy because they are high in vitamin A, and that includes fish liver oil. If you have eaten liver and you are worried, speak to your GP, midwife or pharmacist, as the NHS advises.
Is retinol safe in pregnancy?
No, the NHS advises avoiding vitamin pills and multivitamins that contain vitamin A as retinol during pregnancy, because too much vitamin A can harm the baby’s development. Check the label for the word retinol, and ask your midwife before using any product that lists it.
Does vitamin A harm the baby?
Too much vitamin A can. The NHS says too much can harm the baby’s development, and MedlinePlus says large amounts of vitamin A in pregnant women can cause birth defects. The warnings name liver, liver products and retinol, and neither page names ordinary orange vegetables as a risk.
Which foods give vitamin A in pregnancy?
Orange and yellow fruits and vegetables such as carrots, sweet potatoes, mangos and cantaloupe are the everyday plant sources, and the body can turn their beta carotene into vitamin A. Liver and liver products are the animal source the NHS asks you to avoid in pregnancy.
Why is liver avoided in pregnancy?
Liver is high in vitamin A, and the NHS puts liver and liver products on the avoid list for pregnancy for that reason.
What is the difference between beta carotene and vitamin A?
Beta carotene is the plant form, and the body can convert it into vitamin A. Retinol is the preformed form found in animal foods, and the NHS advice names it. Check the label for that word.
What should I look for on a pregnancy multivitamin label?
Find the vitamin A line in the nutrition panel. If the product contains retinol, the NHS advises avoiding it in pregnancy, so show it to your midwife before using it. If it lists beta carotene, still ask your midwife, because the rest of the label and your diet matter.
Can I take a vitamin pill that lists beta carotene in pregnancy?
The NHS advice names retinol and does not mention beta carotene, so beta carotene is not the item it warns about by name. Even so, ask your midwife or GP before starting any vitamin pill, because they can check the full label against your diet and your other care.
When should I see a doctor about vitamin A?
Speak to your GP, midwife or pharmacist if you have eaten liver regularly or taken a product that lists retinol and you are worried, as the NHS advises. If you feel unwell after taking a vitamin product, see a doctor the same day.