Fruits & Vegetables

Which Shakarkandi Has Beta Carotene? The Cut Test Answer (Video)

Read the full written guide: Orange Shakarkandi Beta Carotene: Which Root Has More? →

Which shakarkandi actually has beta carotene? A 2020 Tanzanian study found orange-fleshed roots carried it while white-fleshed ones had none detectable. This video breaks down how to check the flesh before you buy, how cooking affects it, and what a simple everyday portion looks like.

You'll learn the one market trick that saves you every time, plus what to keep in mind if you manage blood sugar. Head to thecareonline.com for the full article.

Show the full transcript

Transcript

Which shakarkandi has beta carotene? Stay for the one market trick that tells you.

Which shakarkandi has beta carotene? Stay for the one market trick that tells you.

Which Root Has More?

Here's the short, honest answer, and one tip most people miss.

Orange vs White: The Study

Here's the thing: a 2020 study from Tanzania actually tested this. They looked at orange-fleshed and white-fleshed shakarkandi, and the difference was stark. Orange flesh had measurable beta carotene, that's the plant form your body can turn into vitamin A. White flesh? None that could be detected. So the colour inside the root tells you everything.

White Flesh: Zero Detected

Now, the part most people miss. The study didn't say white flesh had a little beta carotene. It said it was below detection levels. Basically zero. So if you're buying shakarkandi for vitamin A, the white ones aren't going to give you that. The number to remember is zero, and it changes how you shop.

Check the Flesh First

So what should you do? The outside doesn't tell you much. Here's the trick: ask the seller to cut one root across the middle, and look at the flesh in daylight, not under a shop light. Firm roots without soft spots are the baseline, but flesh colour is the real clue. If the seller won't cut one, buy from a different shop.

Boiling Beats Frying

Does cooking kill the beta carotene? Not completely, but the method matters. In that study, boiling kept more beta carotene than frying. So if carotene is your goal, steaming or boiling beats frying in the kadhai. The study didn't test roasting, so nobody can honestly give you a roasting number. Keep it simple.

White Roots Still Work

But does that mean white shakarkandi is useless? Not at all. It's still a lovely root to cook with. If your recipe calls for a pale mash, or you want that texture, go ahead and use it. Just know you're not getting beta carotene from it. Choose based on what the dish needs, and reach for orange when carotene is the goal.

A Simple Everyday Plate

How much makes a simple everyday plate? Think household portions, not grams. One medium root, or a katori of mashed or cubed shakarkandi with dal and a green vegetable, that's a nice simple plate. And if you manage blood sugar, don't change anything without talking to your doctor or dietitian first. They're the ones who set your plan.

Take Care If...

One more thing. MedlinePlus notes that eating a lot of beta carotene can turn your skin slightly yellow or orange. It's harmless and fades once you cut back. But if the colour doesn't fade, see a doctor. And if you manage blood sugar, your doctor or dietitian is your best guide, not some blog post.

The One Market Trick

Now, the one trick that saves you every time. Next time you're at the market, ask the seller to cut one root across the middle. Look at the flesh in daylight. Then take a photo with your phone. You now have a reference picture from that shop, so next visit you can match the colour without a knife. That's the whole game.

Like, subscribe and comment

Useful? Like and subscribe, and tell us in the comments what we should check next.

Read the full guide

The full guide is on thecareonline.com. General information only, so check with your doctor for your own case.

Nothing on The Care Online is medical advice. Traditional practices are described as tradition, not as fact. Take a persistent or serious concern to a qualified professional. See how videos and posts are made on our methodology page.