Mix Dal (Panchmel Daal): Which Daals Cook Together and How Long

“Mutthi bhar har daal ki,” a fistful of every daal in the jar, is how a lot of households make mix daal, and it’s why so many pots come out with mushy masoor and rock-hard chana side by side. The fix is to group daals by cooking time: masoor, moong and arhar cook together happily, while chana daal and mash need an hour’s soak to catch up. Here’s how to cook mix dal in a pressure cooker or a pot, a base ratio that works every time, a Rajasthani panchmel daal and a Pakistani dhaba-style mix daal.

Which daals can be mixed? Pair them by cooking time

Any daals can share a pot. Timing is the catch. Daals fall into rough groups by how long they take to soften, and the most forgiving mix daal comes from the fast and middle groups, which finish within a few minutes of each other even if you never measure a thing.

Masoor, moong and arhar need no planning. A mix of just those three makes a smooth everyday daal, while adding chana daal and mash gives more body and bite, but only if they’ve soaked first, because otherwise the masoor dissolves into soup long before the chana has even begun to soften.

Here’s the trick: you don’t want every daal to finish in the same state. A good mix daal has masoor and moong melting into a creamy base while chana and arhar keep some shape, and that contrast is what people mean when they say mix daal tastes “fuller” than a single one.

How to cook mix dal in a pressure cooker

Makes about 5 katoris. Works with any mix of split daals.

1. Measure 1 cup of mixed daal, for example 1/4 cup each of red masoor, dhuli moong, arhar and chana daal.
2. Stagger the soak. Put the chana daal (and any mash) in warm water first, add the arhar to the same bowl after 1 hour and the masoor and moong 15 minutes after that, so everything comes out of the water together.
3. Wash the lot 2 to 3 times. Drain.
4. Cooker: daal, 3.5 cups water, 1/2 tsp haldi, 1 tsp ghee or oil. Keep it under half full.
5. Cook on high to the first whistle, then 6 to 8 minutes on low. That’s about 3 to 4 whistles on a medium flame.
6. Wait. Let the pressure drop by itself.
7. Whisk lightly with a mathani, add 1 tsp salt, and loosen with hot water to the thickness you like.
8. Add the tarka (below) and simmer 3 to 4 minutes so it blends in.

How many whistles for mix dal in a pressure cooker? About 3 to 4 on medium heat if the slower daals were soaked. Skip the soak and it can take 5 to 6, by which point the masoor is paste. Minutes beat whistles.

No cooker? Soak the same way and simmer in 4 to 4.5 cups of water for 45 to 50 minutes, lid tilted, stirring every 10 minutes. Single-daal times, if you’re adapting, are in the Grains, Daals & Pulses guides.

Rajasthani panchmel daal

Panchmel means “five mixed”. It’s the daal served with baati across Rajasthan, thick enough to spoon rather than pour, built on five daals in equal parts and richer than an everyday mix because it leans on mash and chana. Did you know? Baati is a hard ball of wheat dough roasted in embers or baked, then cracked open and dunked in ghee, and the daal is kept thick so it clings.

1. Daals: 3 tbsp each of arhar, chana daal, chilka moong, chilka urad (or dhuli mash) and red masoor. That’s just under 1 cup, for 4 people.
2. Soak chana and urad for 2 hours, adding the arhar and moong after 1 hour and the masoor for the last 15 minutes.
3. Cook in 3 cups water with 1/2 tsp haldi and 1 tsp salt: first whistle, then 7 to 8 minutes on low, natural release. Mash lightly; it should stay thick.
4. Tarka: heat 2 tbsp ghee. Add 1 tsp jeera, 2 cloves, 1 small tej patta, 2 dried red chillies and a pinch of hing.
5. Add 1 tsp grated ginger and 1 chopped green chilli, then 1 chopped tomato, 1 tsp dhania powder and 1/2 tsp lal mirch. Cook 4 to 5 minutes until the tomato breaks down and the ghee separates.
6. Pour into the daal, simmer 5 minutes, finish with 1/4 tsp garam masala and chopped hara dhania.

Pakistani mix daal, dhaba style

The mix daal on Pakistani dhaba menus is usually masoor, moong, mash and chana daal, cooked thick and finished at the table with a sizzling garlic and onion bhagar. It’s a Friday lunch with naan in many homes. Thick is the point.

1. Daals: 1/4 cup each of red masoor, dhuli moong, dhuli mash and chana daal. Soak the mash and chana for 1.5 hours, the other two for the last 15 minutes.
2. Cook in 3 cups water with 1/2 tsp haldi, 1 tsp salt and 1 tsp crushed lal mirch: first whistle, then 6 to 7 minutes on low. Keep it thick.
3. Bhagar: fry 1 sliced onion in 3 tbsp oil or ghee until deep golden, about 8 to 10 minutes. Add 1 tsp zeera, 4 sliced garlic cloves and 3 whole dried red chillies, and fry until the garlic is just golden.
4. Pour the sizzling bhagar over the daal in the serving bowl. Top with julienned ginger, 2 slit green chillies and chopped dhania.

If mash is new to you, it’s the daal that gives this dish its silky pull; our mash daal guide covers it on its own.

Does mix dal cause gas?

About as much as the daals in it. A mix heavy on mash and chana daal feels heavier and gassier to many people than one built on masoor and dhuli moong, and the cause isn’t the mixing at all but the slow-digesting sugars (oligosaccharides) that every pulse carries and that some guts simply handle better than others.

• Soak the slower daals and throw away the soaking water.
• Cook until fully soft. Undercooked chana is the worst offender.
• Add a pinch of hing and some ginger in the tarka, the way every desi kitchen does. How much hing is right is in our hing guide.
• Keep the portion to one or two katoris and build up slowly if you’re not used to daal.

Persistent bloating, pain or a change in bowel habits is not a daal problem to solve at home; see a doctor.

Mix dal protein per bowl, honestly

A katori (about 150 g) of thick mix daal gives roughly 7 to 10 g of protein. Thin daal gives less. That’s close to any single split daal, since masoor, moong, arhar, chana daal and mash are all broadly similar, somewhere around a fifth to a quarter protein by dry weight.

Did you know? One cup of dry split daal swells to about two and a half to three cups once cooked, so the protein printed on a raw-daal label is spread across several katoris by the time it reaches your plate, which is exactly why “per 100 g” figures always look so much bigger than what’s actually sitting in your bowl. Mind the gap. How that fits your day is covered in how much protein you actually need.

Myth: more daals in the pot means more protein

It doesn’t. Five daals give you the average of the five, not the sum. Mix daal earns its place on taste, texture, variety and the happy fact that it uses up the last handful in several jars at once, but it isn’t a protein upgrade on a good bowl of arhar or moong, and what really raises protein per katori is simply thicker daal or a second helping.

Mix daal questions people search